The Nahua Narrative Analysis Essay

The Nahua Narrative Analysis Essay

Length: 992 words (2.8 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

There are a number of reasons the Nahua might have omitted Christianity from their section of the Florentine Codex. Among these reasons a few stand out and merit further exploration. The Nahua narrative may have been closer to the truth than Cortes' account; he may have overplayed the Christian side of the conquest to make it appear more humane. Perhaps Sahagun initially censored sections about Christianity. On the other hand, the Nahua may not have seen it as a main factor in the conquest.
Many places in Book XII the Nahua refer to instances where Cortes is very cruel to the natives. This is in sharp contrast to a more peaceful conversion that he described at times. The Nahua writes use a very flowery writing style to convey their ideas. Often when translated to Spanish these passages are made short, crisp and much less brutal. One example raised in a paper by Kevin Terraciano on pg. 61 occurs when the codex describes how the Spanish sacked a Calacoyan. The Nahua say, “They started killing and stabbing people. They did not give notice to the people of Calacoyan; unexpectedly they were killed. The Spaniards took out their rage on them, vented their wrath on them when they had done the killing.1” When translated to Spanish this passage reads “They destroyed that whole settlement.2” This passage shows how significant the changes into Spanish could be. In another section, the Nahua describe the Spanish reaction to gold as animal like. How they grabbed at it like monkeys, as if they were starved. The Spanish twisted this to say that the natives observed the Spanish “rejoicing over the gold, which they held in high esteem.3” Another much more pro-Spanish interpretation of the Nahua text. Patterns such as this support the idea that t...

... middle of paper ...

...sualty counts, however I think some of this has to be due to the significance the artists put on showing the suffering of the Nahua. Alternatively, we can see that we fail to understand the complex nuances of Nahuatl even today. For example the meaning of teotl is not fully understood. When used to refer to Cortes and the conquistadors it has generally been taken to mean “god.” Many books show this by saying that the Aztecs viewed the Spaniards as gods. However, more recent scholarship has shown the meaning of teotl to be more abstract. Its connotations reach to more abstract ideas such as “beyond the ordinary8” or “fine, fancy, large, powerful and so on.9” It seems likely that the Spanish took teotl to be the analogue of dios, which strictly means god, in the Judaeo-Christian sense. While was not an inaccurate use of the word, it is not the only way it could be used.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Narrative Analysis : ' Illness Narratives ' Essay

- Narrative analysis within anthropology has been predominantly associated with research appertaining to ‘illness narratives’, defined by Kleinman (1988) as stories people afflicted with illness tell, and their significant others retell, to accordingly express an orderly sequence of events over the course of suffering. Atkinson (1997:331), however, criticised this interpretation of the illness narrative for introducing an “isolated actor who experiences and narrates as a matter of private and privileged experience”....   [tags: Sociology, Anthropology, Culture, Identity]

Better Essays
1474 words (4.2 pages)

Slave Narrative Literary Analysis Essay

- Prior to the publication of any slave narrative, African Americans had been represented by early historians’ interpretations of their race and culture. Commonly accepted gender roles are a product of the biological and social evolution of humankind and are polarized between masculine and feminine expressions. These roles have been universally adapted and historically assigned to individuals based on gender. The collective acceptance of individual gender roles has fashioned them into a lens through which all human experience is filtered down to the individual....   [tags: Literary Analysis ]

Better Essays
1072 words (3.1 pages)

Literary Analysis: Slave Narratives Essays

- Prior to the publication of any slave narrative, African Americans had been represented by early historians’ interpretations of their race, culture, and situation along with contemporary authors’ fictionalized depictions. Their persona was often “characterized as infantile, incompetent, and...incapable of achievement” (Hunter-Willis 11) while the actions of slaveholders were justified with the arguments that slavery would maintain a cheap labor force and a guarantee that their suffering did not differ to the toils of the rest of the “struggling world” (Hunter-Willis 12)....   [tags: Literary Analysis ]

Better Essays
1204 words (3.4 pages)

Analysis Of Edwin S. Porter 's Narrative Side Essay

- Iman Ahad Professor Kuntz T.A. Aruna Ekanayake FTV 106A 29 October 2014 Edwin S. Porter’s Narrative Side Cinema is a relatively new and highly creative medium. Since its coming, the variety of films yielded have been remarkable. In the early stages of film, there were many things to learn and many paths to go down. Given these circumstances, film most indubitable necessity was to have some pioneers working to perfect the ever-changing art form. One of the greatest and most notable of these pioneers is the great Edwin S....   [tags: Film, Narrative, Film editing, The Fireman]

Better Essays
2105 words (6 pages)

Fight Club: A Narrative Analysis Essay

- Barsam and Monahan define a narrative as, “A cinematic structure in which content is selected and arranged in a cause-and-effect sequence of events occurring over time” (553). David Fincher’s Fight Club uses a very unique narrative mode in that the whole film is self-narrated by the unnamed main character and has one of the best surprise endings in this writer’s opinion. This makes the film a prime specimen to be broken apart for further narrative analysis. The film starts out with the nameless narrator played by Edward Norton in a nameless city....   [tags: Cinema]

Better Essays
1548 words (4.4 pages)

Nahua Philosophy Essay

- It has been the goal of any society to try and begin to understand the nature of existence and the connection with an ultimate that humans feel. This searching is often human nature and leads different cultures around the world to describe the human problematic in many different ways. For the Nauha, a native Mexican tribe, the surface of the earth (tlalticpac) is slippery and narrow like a jagged path following mountain peeks. With a world view as such people having to walk along this dangerous path the look for ways to keep their balance and maintain their lives....   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
835 words (2.4 pages)

Slavery and The Narrative of Frederick Douglass Essay

- Slavery and The Narrative of Frederick Douglass In 1845, Frederick Douglass told his compelling story of life as slave and as a free man. Through the words of somebody who endured slavery, we can only get a taste of what it was like, for we will never truly know the feeling of the severe physical punishment and the cruelty the slaves endured. Whippings, beatings and lynchings were all too common during the era of slavery. However, not only were their bodies treated so harshly, but their minds and souls were as well....   [tags: The Narrative of Frederick Douglass]

Better Essays
582 words (1.7 pages)

Narrative as Determination of the Future Anterior Essay example

- Narrative as Determination of the Future Anterior Narrative, it seems banal to observe, opens a space. This space is not so much a place of play for unlimited possibilities (although in the best of possible worlds it might yet be) as somewhere determined, always, in advance, by the future anterior: what will have happened and how it will already have taken place lure us through stories to their ends, become the end that shines through from the very start. Reading for the ending: in narrative, the end justifies the means; the end is the means....   [tags: Narratives Writing Transsexuals Gender Essays]

Free Essays
1504 words (4.3 pages)

Essay about Personal Narative- Tough Girl

- Personal Narative- Tough Girl She went to the land of Hollywood with a diamond wedding necklace hanging loosely from her neck like a noose before it gives its snapping goodbye. She went to the land of dreams with pride coloring her shadow; a haughty swing of her thick plait; and why not. Her name was Serina –she was named after a dream. Why not. I thought, though I cried the night before because she got the chance bestowed to her curvy hips, her white Colgate smile, her crystal blue eyes. And what about me....   [tags: Personal Narrative Writing]

Free Essays
1367 words (3.9 pages)

Essay about Slave Narratives

- The slave narratives of the ante-bellum time period have come across numerous types of themes. Much of the work concentrates on the underlining ideas beneath the stories. In the narratives, fugitives and ex-slaves appealed to the humanity they shared with their readers during these times, men being lynched and marked all over and women being the subject of grueling rapes. "The slave narrative of Frederick Douglas" and "Harriet Jacobs: Incidents in the Life of a Slave Girl" themes come from the existence of the slaves morality that they are forced compromise to live....   [tags: Thematic Analysis, Discrimination]

Better Essays
869 words (2.5 pages)